Enrolling in a Dependent Care FSA?How to claim up to $7,500
Skip to main content
Save $408/year on the subscription

NannyKeeper vs Poppins Payroll

Nanny payroll made simple. Here's how NannyKeeper compares, and why families are making the switch.

Recommended

NannyKeeper

Comparing

Poppins Payroll

Monthly price
$18/mo
$49/mo
Year-end fee
Included
Included
Direct deposit
$6/transfer (Plus), $8/transfer (Starter), +0.8% over $1,000
Included
Annual total
$180
$588
Unlimited payroll runs
Federal + state tax calculations
Quarterly tax support
W-2 generation
Schedule H preparation
Direct deposit
Email deadline reminders
All 50 states supported
Works with AI assistants

✕ means the feature isn't listed on that provider's own pages (checked September 2026).

About Poppins Payroll

Poppins Payroll is a mid-range nanny payroll service that positions itself as a friendlier alternative to the big players. They offer full-service payroll, meaning they handle tax filings on your behalf, at a more reasonable price than HomePay.

What Poppins Payroll does well

  • Full-service: they file taxes on your behalf
  • Reasonable monthly pricing
  • Good customer support reputation
  • Year-end filing and direct deposit included

Where Poppins Payroll falls short

  • Email deadline reminders not listed on its pages
  • No free tier for payment tracking
  • Limited mobile experience

Why families switch to NannyKeeper

  • Save $408 a year if you pay your nanny yourself, or about $252 with direct deposit every two weeks on paychecks up to $1,000
  • Get email deadline reminders included
  • Modern, easy-to-use interface
  • Free payment tracking tier for families just starting out

Calculate what leaving Poppins Payroll costs now versus on January 1

Pricing verified October 2026. Verify current pricing on each provider's website.

Save $408 every year on the subscription

That's $2,040 over 5 years on the subscription, for the same tax forms. Pay your nanny by direct deposit every two weeks on paychecks up to $1,000 and it is about $252 a year, since Poppins Payroll includes direct deposit and we charge $6 a transfer, plus 0.8% of anything over $1,000. Calculate yours.

Enough for date nights, a family outing, or just keeping more of your money.

Get started free

No credit card required • Cancel anytime

Before you switch

Check what the IRS would flag about your current setup

If you've been running payroll on Poppins Payroll, there may be compliance gaps worth knowing before you migrate. The free audit simulator takes 60 seconds and shows specific dollar exposure: FICA, Schedule H, state SUTA, 1099 misclassification.

Run the IRS audit simulator

What you get with NannyKeeper

Automatic tax calculations

Federal, state, and local taxes calculated for every paycheck. All 50 states supported.

Direct deposit available

Pay your nanny directly to their bank account. Starting at $6/transfer, plus 0.8% on amounts over $1,000 per transfer.

W-2 and Schedule H

Year-end forms generated and ready for you to file. No surprise fees.

Email deadline reminders

We remind you before quarterly deadlines so you never miss a payment.

Pay stubs

Professional pay stubs for every paycheck, great for your nanny's records.

State requirement tracking

We track what's required in your state and remind you of deadlines.

A note on full-service vs self-service: NannyKeeper is a self-service platform. We calculate taxes, generate W-2s and Schedule H, and remind you of deadlines, but you handle the actual filing with the IRS, SSA, and your state. Competitors like HomePay, GTM, Poppins, and SurePayroll offer full-service filing, meaning they file taxes on your behalf at a higher monthly cost.

One thing worth knowing: full-service asks more of you than it looks. To file on your behalf, the provider has you sign authorizations over your tax accounts. And it doesn't actually move the responsibility off you: household employment taxes are reported on your own 1040 (Schedule H), under your own Social Security number, so the IRS looks to the family no matter who submits the forms. The guarantees say so in the fine print too: they cover a penalty if the provider made the mistake, but never the tax itself. We've even had families come to us after a provider missed something for years, or simply didn't file what they were paying for, and left them to sort it out with the IRS. With NannyKeeper you stay in control, see exactly how every number was calculated, pay the IRS directly (about 15 minutes a quarter), and save every year on the subscription.

Frequently asked questions

How much does Poppins Payroll cost?
Poppins Payroll costs $49/month, totaling approximately $588/year. NannyKeeper's Plus plan is $18/month ($180/year on annual billing), saving you $408/year on the subscription. On Plus, direct deposit, which Poppins Payroll includes, is $6 a transfer, plus 0.8% of anything over $1,000. Starter is $100/year and costs less, unless you pay your nanny by direct deposit every week, where Plus's lower $6 transfer fee wins.
Is Poppins Payroll worth it?
Poppins Payroll offers full-service: they file taxes on your behalf, which is valuable if you prefer a hands-off approach. Just keep in mind that the responsibility stays with you either way: household taxes are reported under your own Social Security number on Schedule H, and the full-service guarantees only ever cover a penalty if the provider erred, never the tax itself. At $588/year it costs more than self-service on the subscription, so if you're comfortable submitting your own forms (it's straightforward), a self-service tool like NannyKeeper gives you the same calculations and documents for a smaller subscription. If you pay by direct deposit, our switching calculator compares the full cost, transfer fees included.
What's the cheapest nanny payroll service?
NannyKeeper is the most affordable full-featured nanny payroll service, starting at $10/month ($100/year on annual billing) for the Starter plan. It includes federal and state tax calculations, W-2 generation, Schedule H preparation, and email deadline reminders. There's also a free tier for basic payment tracking.
Can I switch from Poppins Payroll to NannyKeeper?
Yes. Switching is straightforward: you can enter your employee's information and any prior wages paid this year when setting up NannyKeeper. Your prior payroll history stays with your previous provider, but NannyKeeper will handle all calculations going forward and account for wages already paid when generating year-end documents.