Enrolling in a Dependent Care FSA?How to claim up to $7,500
Skip to main content
2026 Pricing

Nanny Payroll Cost Comparison

Enter your nanny's pay to see your employer taxes and the subscription price of every payroll service, side by side.

Share this:
$

What you keep vs. HomePay (5 yrs)

$4,000

with NannyKeeper Starter

Your nanny earns

$41,600/yr

Your employer taxes

$3,469/yr

Every service calculates the same taxes. The only difference is what you pay for the service.

Try NannyKeeper Free
ServiceMonthly CostAnnual Cost

NannyKeeper (Starter)Cheapest

$10/mo$100/yr

NannyKeeper (Plus)Best Value

$18/mo$180/yr

HomePay

$75/mo$900/yr

GTM

$70/mo$840/yr

Poppins

$49/mo$588/yr

SurePayroll

$39/mo$468/yr

Subscription price only. Direct deposit transfer fees and optional add-on services (such as GTM's year-end forms) are not included; see each provider's pricing page. NannyKeeper prices are for annual billing. SurePayroll is priced for one nanny. Employer taxes (shown above) are the same regardless of service.

Ready to stop overpaying for nanny payroll?

Start tracking payments for free — no credit card needed. Upgrade to full payroll when you're ready.

Get Started Free
Free forever plan
Payroll from $10/mo
All 50 states
Cancel anytime

Common questions about nanny payroll costs

Found this useful? Share it:

Start with NannyKeeper for free

Track payments at no cost. Upgrade to payroll when you're ready — starting at $10/month.

Get Started Free
No credit card required
W-2 & Schedule H included
Deadline reminders