2026 Pricing
Nanny Payroll Cost Comparison
Enter your nanny's pay to see the real annual cost of every payroll service — side by side.
$
What you keep vs. HomePay (5 yrs)
$4,010
with NannyKeeper Starter
Your nanny earns
$41,600/yr
Your employer taxes
$3,462/yr
Every service calculates the same taxes. The only difference is what you pay for the service.
Try NannyKeeper Free| Service | Monthly Cost | Direct Deposit | Annual Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
NannyKeeper (Starter)Cheapest | $10/mo | $1.50/payroll | $198/yr |
NannyKeeper (Plus)Best Value | $18/mo | Included | $216/yr |
HomePay | $75/mo | Included | $1,000/yr |
GTM | $70/mo | Included | $840/yr |
Poppins | $49/mo | Included | $588/yr |
SurePayroll | $39/mo | Included | $468/yr |
Annual cost = monthly service fee + year-end fee + direct deposit fees. Employer taxes (shown above) are the same regardless of service.
Ready to stop overpaying for nanny payroll?
Start tracking payments for free — no credit card needed. Upgrade to full payroll when you're ready.
Get Started FreeFree forever plan
Payroll from $10/mo
All 50 states
Cancel anytime
Common questions about nanny payroll costs
Start with NannyKeeper for free
Track payments at no cost. Upgrade to payroll when you're ready — starting at $10/month.
Get Started FreeNo credit card required
W-2 & Schedule H included
Deadline reminders